What Is Motivated Reasoning?

We are not always—in fact, we are probably not often—the objective, rational creatures we like to think we are. Psychologists have had a field day in the past couple of decades demonstrating the many ways we deceive ourselves through our very processes of reasoning. While indeed our cognitive faculties are a distinguishing feature of humanity—they have lifted us out of caves and enabled all of the arts and sciences—they are also rooted in and subject to influence, or bias, by our emotions and deeply wired instincts. One of the most significant ways we warp our information processing and reasoning—and we do it outside of awareness that anything psychologically sneaky is going on—is called motivated reasoning.

It’s easiest to understand when seen in operation. Cognitive scientists see motivated reasoning as a force that operates in the realm of political beliefs, particularly relating to such topics as climate change. Studies by political psychologists highlight denial of global warming or discrediting the science about it as an important example of motivated reasoning, whereby some people process scientific information about climate shifts to conform to pre-existing feelings and beliefs. After all, accepting that climate change is real portends unpleasant environmental consequences and would require most people to head them off by making significant changes in lifestyle. Changing one’s mind and changing one’s lifestyle are hard work and we prefer shortcuts, the goal to which we’d rather fit our conclusions.

Motivated reasoning operates in much more personal spheres as well. For example, it is seen as a mechanism people commonly use to preserve a favorable identity, particularly in the Western world. In order to maintain positive self-regard, people (unwitting) discount unflattering information that contradicts their self-image or is otherwise troubling.

We engage in motivated reasoning as a way to avoid or lessen cognitive dissonance, the mental discomfort we experience when confronted by contradictory information, especially on matters that directly relate to our well-being.

Recent posts on Motivated Reasoning

Marriage Alone Does Not Make You a Better Person

When I got married, I was young, weak, wimpy, unconscious, and inexperienced.

Why Do People Believe in Conspiracy Theories?

By David Ludden Ph.D. on January 06, 2018 in Talking Apes
Belief in conspiracy theories can satisfy important psychological needs for some people. We need to understand this first before confronting a believer with facts.

The Arguing Ape Hypothesis

The problem with contemporary political discourse is not bias and laziness. It's tribalism.
zinkevych / 123RF Stock Photo

How Confirmation Bias Affects You Every Single Day

By F. Diane Barth L.C.S.W. on December 31, 2017 in Off the Couch
Confirmation bias affects you more than you realize. What is it and how does it work?

Do You See What I See?

By Nathan A Heflick Ph.D. on December 29, 2017 in The Big Questions
Do our goals and motivations influence what we see?

Adaptation? It's Way Different For Humans

By Jeremy E Sherman Ph.D. on December 21, 2017 in Ambigamy
Adaptation—good fit to reality—is as old as life but very different for humans given our power of language. Here we imagine a beginner's guide for us newfangled language users.

Tales of the Primally Wounded

By Darcia Narvaez Ph.D. on December 20, 2017 in Moral Landscapes
Our ancestors pulled together with stories of cooperation told by the community's storytellers. Today we are pulled apart by fear-promoting stories. Here are some of those stories.

Reflective Judgment

Going with your gut is not always the best policy – to think critically, you need reflective judgment.

Is Psychology a "Self-Correcting" Science?

By Lee Jussim Ph.D. on December 06, 2017 in Rabble Rouser
Is psychology a science? If so, where is the "scientific self-correction"?
Wikipedia Commons / Public Domain

How The Greatest Minds Solve Problems: Thinking Partners

By Al Pittampalli on December 06, 2017 in Are You Persuadable?
Arguing with someone else might the best way to make decisions, science reveals.

Does Science Require a Leap of Faith?

By David Ludden Ph.D. on December 04, 2017 in Talking Apes
No one has ever changed their essential beliefs on the basis of rational arguments.
Dino Reichmuth/Unsplash

The Intuition of Truth

By Ryan Smerek, Ph.D. on December 01, 2017 in Learning at Work
Why we should engage our intuitive reaction around truth.

Be Your Own Hero

Albert Einstein talked about this kind of respect when he wrote: "A human being is part of the whole called by us 'universe', a part limited in time and space..."

Roy Moore's Systemic Danger to Our Democracy

By Gleb Tsipursky Ph.D. on November 16, 2017 in Intentional Insights
Concerned about Roy Moore? This post shows how his accusations are a systemic danger to our democracy.

The Art of Parenting

You have more time to be a good parent today than you will ever have again. Take advantage of your good fortune!

Ordinary Magic

Intimacy is so often contained in the ordinary moments: a lingering gaze, a brief touch, a hug, a gentle word of encouragement.

The Power of Ritual

Rituals are actions that support the deepening of our spiritual and emotional connections. They bring extra brightness and fulfillment into our lives.
Guma89/Wikimedia Commons

When Do We Change Our Minds? Think of a Jenga Tower

By Ryan Smerek, Ph.D. on October 18, 2017 in Learning at Work
The next time you seem to be in an intractable conflict, think about where you are in the Jenga Tower (and what this says about belief centrality).

Confirmation Bias: Why You Make Terrible Life Choices

By Nir Eyal on October 17, 2017 in Automatic You
Confirmation bias is a cognitive shortcut that can lead to some pretty horrendous decisions. Here's how to recognize and overcome it in your life.
Pixabay

Stop and Smell the Roses

5 steps to stop letting the rush rule win and start turning your attention to what’s along the way.

Myth-busting About Open-mindedness

By Jeremy E Sherman Ph.D. on September 20, 2017 in Ambigamy
Becoming more open-minded isn't just saying you're open-minded or deciding to think out the box. It's disciplining yourself to follow out harder thoughts.

The Blame Game: We Love to Blame Others, But Why?

By Rob Henderson on August 29, 2017 in After Service
Why do we love blaming others? Research explains this quirk in our psychology.

I'm Not In The Mood

We all wake up to a new day. The question is, will our mood for the day control how the day goes or do we control the mood. What will be your mood for the day? Happy or grumpy?

The Irrationality of Marriage

By Katherine Hawley Ph.D. on August 06, 2017 in Trust
How can we commit whole-heartedly, when we know divorce is so common?

Failure to Listen

By Marty Nemko Ph.D. on August 04, 2017 in How To Do Life
A short-short story about suppression and commitment bias.

Why Do Your Facebook Friends Have So Much Political Bias?

Myside bias makes us notice, search for, and favor evidence that supports what we already believe. Why do we do this? And is it worse on social media?

Be the CEO of Your Life

By Steve Sisgold on July 31, 2017 in Life in a Body
“Are you living proactively or reactively?”

Hypotheses About Gender Imbalance in Expressing Opinions

By John A. Johnson Ph.D. on July 21, 2017 in Cui Bono
Why are more opinion letters published in the NYT written by male authors? I explore both hypotheses about the answer to this question and how theories determine our hypotheses.

Rallying the Troops Versus Quieting the Indignation

By Gregory R. Maio Ph.D. on July 10, 2017 in Attitude Check
Is open-mindedness enough to make us more tolerant of other groups?

No Confessing Our Partner’s Sins

For so many of us, the tendency to think in judgmental terms and to see ourselves as a victim is strong.