The Seven Deadly Sins of Toxic Management

Toxic leadership wears many masks, disguising itself in subtle behaviors and statements.

Source: NIC LAW / Pexels

Toxic management can manifest in various ways, including lack of integrity, egotism, and a focus on personal ambition rather than the well-being of others. These behaviors can have severe consequences for employees, such as psychological distress, withdrawal, and reduced job satisfaction.

In my mission to detox management, I've discovered that everyone supports the idea of detoxing management in theory. But few recognize their own role in perpetuating the problem. We managers can become deft in using words and actions that hide their noxious effects.

This insidious phenomenon often hides in plain sight, masked by seemingly innocuous phrases and behaviors. As a leader, it's crucial to be aware of these subtle red flags, as they can slowly erode your team's morale, productivity, and well-being. Keep an eye out for these seven telling signs:

1. Revolving door. "It's so hard to find good people these days." When leaders struggle to retain employees across multiple teams, it's time to consider if they might be the underlying issue.
2. Happy talk. "I've got an open door policy, but no one ever complains." If your employees rarely come to you with their concerns or ideas, it may indicate that they fear your reaction or criticism.
3. Emotional manipulation. "I'm not sure the rest of the team gets how important this is, so I'm really glad I've got someone like you on the team who gets it." Using flattery, guilt, or other emotional tactics to control your team and get your way is a clear sign of toxic leadership.
4. Celebrating sacrifice. "Thanks for putting in those extra hours over the weekend. That's the kind of dedication we need around here." Praising and normalizing overwork can lead to burnout and resentment among your team members.
5. Micromanagement in disguise. "It's completely up to you how to approach this. Just walk me through your approach one more time." While pretending to empower your team, constantly requiring them to seek your approval and justify their decisions can stifle their growth and autonomy.
6. Patronizing gatekeeper. "I know this is a new area for you, so let's stick with what we know works for now." Regularly dismissing ideas and defaulting to the status quo can dampen your team's motivation and creativity.
7. Teflon boss. "I gave them clear instructions, but somehow they still managed to drop the ball." Toxic managers are skilled at shifting responsibility and pointing fingers when projects or initiatives fail. This behavior erodes trust and leaves employees feeling unsupported and demotivated.

This list can help managers become more self aware, and it can help you recognize if you are being managed in a harmful way. If you find yourself on the receiving end of bad behaviors, it may be time to have an honest conversation with your manager or seek guidance from a trusted leader. Your mental health and physical well-being are more valuable than any job.

It's worth noting that the same leader can exhibit a mixture of toxic and empowering behaviors, creating unique profiles. This complexity underscores the importance of self-awareness and the need for managers to continually assess and improve their leadership style.

Toxic Management can be the spark that ignites a destructive fire within your team

Source: Pixabay / Pexels

If you catch yourself using any of these phrases, take a long, hard look in the mirror. If you hear these phrases, or similar ones, it may be time to reflect on a plan of action. Recognizing these subtle signs of toxic management is the first step towards detoxing the workplace. Start by being mindful of your language, fostering open communication, and prioritizing your team's well-being. Remember, your team's success and engagement are direct reflections of your leadership.

The detox process begins with awareness — of self and others. Share this list with your fellow managers and start a conversation about how you can collectively create a more positive, empowering workplace.

Together, we can save lives, boost performance, and build a brighter future for everyone. Remember, the first step to detoxing management is recognizing the problem. The second step is taking action to create change. It starts with you.