The People's Professor

Psychology 360: A brain-behavior buffet, heavy to lite, A to Z

The Zimmerman Effect: Are We Losing Perspective on Horror?

With so much horror needing our concern, this trial coverage is overdone.

The 21st century's Tower of Babel has been found. Its the media coverage of the Zimmerman trial. In a world of horror, with innocent children being slaughtered in conflicts around the world, with the horror of the world's prison systems and the gulag for men and minorities that our own system represents, with the unchained death penalty in the U.S. indexed by a record number of executions in the leading state for State killings,Texas, the media abandons most of these horrific problems that cry out for our attention and devotes untold millions of dollars and thousands of hours to covering one trial, that of George Zimmerman. The death of Trayvon Martin is but one horror in a nation awash in horrors. This case has few or no major aspects of law or nationally relevant points to make. Indeed, racism may be the only point, and racism's role is  unclear and is not an example with implications for most communities. The first revelation of the murder attracted the usual rush of famous clerics, lawyer/pundits and activists. Before much was known about the case, these rush-to-judgment media denizens were everywhere declaring this as a major case of racism. The President weighed in inappropriately, comparing Trayvon Martin to a hypothetical Presidential son. And so this not very notable case of a Florida murder, sad and horrific as every of the approximately 12000 gun homicides in 2012 were, is selected out of all those horrors for total media saturation.

Find a Therapist

Search for a mental health professional near you.

This loss of perspective on the horrors confronting us and our need to deal with them is exacerbated by the relentless babble of the media pundits. Gavel to gavel reporting of every minute detail of this ongoing trial was covered by the media during which period of time hundreds of other Americans are being tried across the nation, some unfairly, some sentenced to inappropriate prison terms or put on death row for something they didn't do (note The Innocence Project), in media silence.

In the Zimmerman trial every nuance of prosecution and defense strategy, witnesses and courtroom performance were debated by media lawyers, anchors, and professional media "contributors" of little-known credentials. No details of education or experience in trial work are presented for most of them. But by the dozens they engage in analyses of human behavior, motivation,emotion, attitude and decision making. They specify what is normal behavior and deviations from it, what one would expect of an individual under this condition or that, and so on. They speculate about the truth-telling of witnesses, about the meaning of demeanor, the nuances of so-called body language that are notoriously unreliable under these conditions, etc. Astoundingly, no or few trained psychologists have been involved in the coverage (I have seen none), people who have spent a lifetime of rigorous study of human behavior, motivation, emotion, attitude and decision making. If we are going to let media punditry direct and inform these discussions and debates in a nation with more rigorously trained Ph.D's in psychology than any country, the quality of the national media debates requires that we draw upon that specialized training.The public deserves no less.

The Zimmerman Effect is the driving out of more urgent and inclusive debates by a less urgent and more narrow debate. A nation should keep perspective on the social and communication expenditures of time and money it allocates, attending to the largest issues of horror in our times.

To summarize, I have drawn two generalizations from the Zimmerman trial: 1) Keep perspective on allocating our national time and energy on the horrors confronting us. The Zimmerman trial saturation deprives the nation of debates on other equal or more pressing issues. As with individuals, nations can deplete their energy, and lose their balance. The vast media coverage raises questions of opportunity costs. What opportunities in our national discussions have been lost due to the obsession with this one trial? 2) Where are the psychologists? Criminal trials are grounded in evidence, usually features of human behavior. Are the nation's law schools grounding their students in solid psychology, in the comprehensive and rigorous study of human behavior? Its not happening.

Apparently you fell into it

Apparently you fell into it yourself, if you're declaring it "murder" from your desk.

I have no television, so was not subjected to the relentless coverage of this case, or the Arias case before it, or the Casey Anthony case, or the OJ Simpson case, etc ad nauseum. I agree that when the media cover such things, they aren't covering other, perhaps more important things, but they aren't obligated to do so. The media loves scandal, titillation, etc, and they prefer things that appear on the surface to be clean cut, black and white, good guy/bad guy. Anything messy and difficult is "too hard" to cover and "too hard" for the public to understand, or that's the excuse they'll use. If you want to know about more important things, you have to turn off the TV and find it yourself.

It's all about what is good for Liberals

It's all about what is good for Liberals -- end of story. Any event or incident, regardless of the pain and suffering it causes, will be used by the Liberals at all levels to advance their cause.

As we see more and more evidence about this case come out, the level of bias in this country demonstrated by the left is hideously immoral. From the President of this country down to the local news media it has been one big attempt to steer the outcome of this trial.

Stirring the pot gets Obama and his team political points by dividing the country, something Liberals are expert at. How can the media do this with Black gang members killing each other in the inner city? That would only rile up tensions within the black and poor communnities, already solid voting blocks for Obama. Plus, analyzing the root causes of much of the agony in those neighborhoods shows that Liberalism is as much to blame as any other cause and we surely don't want that, do we?

Think about all the Liberal caues and power points in this case:

1. Racial hierarchy: Blacks against Hispanics against Whites. The more divisiveness, the more power for Liberals.

2. Gun Control: If only we can outlaw those darn, evil guns can we get better control of the .... I mean can we make the country safer. Like Chicago, Washington D.C., New York and other really safe places with low gun crime rates where guns are outlawed.

3. The right to self protection: From arguments I have heard and witnessed in my life it seems as though Liberals are terrified of having the responsibility of protecting themselves when that is the only option. I guess they are afraid of many self responsibilities so this is nothing unusual. I and every gun owner I know would rather have a cop deal with the bad guy MUCH more than dealing with him myself, but when the bad guy comes at us and no cops are around the last thing one should think of is "Will I get in trouble for protecting my life in this case?"

I heard Trayvon Martin's mom ask for justice for her son. If that comes true, Zimmerman will be found "Not Guilty" and maybe they should investigate Trayvon's mom and dad for not raising their child properly resulting him becoming a gangsta-thug for the self-esteem he should have gotten from his parents.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.

More information about formatting options

Frank Farley, Ph.D., is a L.H. Carnell Professor, Temple University, and former President of the American Psychological Association.


Subscribe to The People's Professor

Current Issue

Let It Go!

It can take a radical reboot to get past old hurts and injustices.