The Interactive World

Techniques for helping your autistic child and the latest news about autism.

Crossing Over

It's counterproductive in politics. It's a disaster in autism.

My entire career, I've been a relationship kind of a guy. More specifically, I've favored taking a relationship-based approach to helping children with autism. The belief was (and is), that when an autistic person pulls away into his own world, this is something to be worked with rather than battled. Allowing children to pull away gives them an opportunity to establish some level of control, take a break, and /or follow a plan. All of these have value if you believe, as I do, the relationship an autistic person has with the others in his life will be a primary motivator for learning skills and, more importantly, consistent and deep interaction.

I still strongly believe in relationship-based approach. That said, in the past six months, I've come to see strong value in table work and trials (traits from the pretty-much-opposite method of Applied Behavioral Analysis).

Even now, looking back, it makes sense: taking the best practices from multiple approaches works in most fields, why wouldn't it work in autism? It sounds great on paper, but there can be huge resistance from professionals who have been practicing one particular method for their entire careers (as I have).

There are two main issues:

1) Most treatments are based on a philosophy and it just plain feels wrong to the professional to go against what they have been taught. It's not the what (of the method), but the why (we might choose to do it) that often counts.
2) As a professional, I think I can safely say this about 95% of my brethren: each of us really think we're doing it the 'right way', so why should we be open to other treatments?

Yet, even as we deeply believe we know what is best for an autistic child, we clearly do not. No method has proven to be consistently powerful enough to effectively banish other methods. Put another way: last I checked, most folks who were once autistic are still autistic.

Listening to behaviorists and relationship-based professionals argue/debate brings to mind the Democrats and Republicans: neither side is usually willing to listen to the other.

It's counterproductive in politics. It's a disaster in autism.



Subscribe to The Interactive World

Jonathan Levy has worked one-on-one with over 800 children with autism, ranging from the severely autistic to the mildest forms of Asperger's syndrome.

more...