The Dance of Connection

Rescuing women and men from the quicksand of difficult relationships.

The Most Overrated Virtue: My Jewish Perspective

Humility can be its own form of arrogance.


I recently sent an e-mail filled with self-pity to my friend, the playwright, Marcia Cebulska. I was having an especially Bad Writing Day. I told Marcia that I had no brain and that our Muse (we share a Muse named Lydia) had abandoned me. I complained that all my good ideas were used up, and, worse still, I probably had early-onset Alzheimers, something I worry about every now and again.

Marcia is kind and generous, and, as a playwright, she knows the agonies of the writing life. But how did she try to comfort me? By emailing me back that I was "wonderful and intelligent."

Wonderful? Intelligent!!! I couldn't have felt more insulted. In my Jewish family where achievement was next to godliness, "intelligent" was a codeword for "above average," which was one of the worst things you could say about a person. The only compliment you could give somebody was "brilliant" or better.

Poor Marcia. She didn't meant to deflate me further. She simply didn't know my vernacular because in her family, it was dangerous to be smart, so they tended to play it down. In order to edify her, I emailed the following code.
In my family there was (from the top down):

1. "Genius" (reserved for Einstein, Leonard Bernstein, and Jonas Salk)
2. "The most brilliant person I ever met"
3. "incredibly brilliant"
4. "Unbelievably brilliant"
5. " Brilliant"
6. " Intelligent" (translate: definitely not brilliant)
7. "Ordinary"
8. "Loser" (schlub, numbskull, schlemiel, etc.)

In her next e-mail Marcia addressed me as, "Oh, Brilliant One," which really wasn't all that flattering since it's only number five on an eight point scale, but oh, well, it was an improvement. Just know that "brilliant" in my family might be the equivalent of "pretty darn good" in yours.

Actually, modesty is the most over-rated virtue. This is especially so for women who are taught to look wide-eyed at other people's ideas, and to downplay their own abilities.

I think we should speak of our successes with the same unapologetic gusto and candor that we speak of our fat thighs and poor memories. People who take great pride in downplaying their accomplishments irritate me. As some wise person once said, humility is its own form of arrogance.

 

 



Subscribe to The Dance of Connection

Harriet Lerner, Ph.D. is best known for her work on marriage and family relationships and the psychology of women. Her latest book is Marriage Rules: A Manual for the Married and the Coupled Up.

more...