The Big Questions

Life, death and free will.

The Devil Made Me (Not) Do It!

Belief in Hell and Immorality

There is a classic study in social psychology that asked criminals and non-criminals if they would commit certain crimes if they knew, 100%, that they would never get caught. The criminals' responses did not differ from the responses of non-criminals. This suggests that all people, criminal or not, have roughly the same desire to commit crimes. The only thing separating them is a fear of, or at least a consideration of, getting caught.

I have a huge interest in the psychological effects of belief in Hell and Satan. And I wondered if this same idea was at play when it comes to Hell. Do people avoid cheating, murdering, raping and stealing because they want to avoid the punishment of Hell?

I had this thought in my head while attending SPSP, a national conference for social psychology, in San Diego a few weeks back. And, low and behold, one of the presentations, by Azim Sharif of the University of Oregon, addressed these very questions.

Sharif and colleagues measured belief in Hell and a variety of anti-social behaviors across several countries. The consistent finding was that the more a nation believed in Hell, the lower the crime rate.

Sharif also presented data showing that when people perceive that God is angry and punitive, they are less likely to cheat, and further, that when people perceive God as forgiving, it is associated with more anti-social behaviors.

Non-criminals presumably don't do criminal acts because they are more aware of, or perhaps scared of, punishment than are criminals, but the desire to commit crimes is roughly the same.

And, it appears the same type of issue is at play when it comes to immoral actions and belief in God(s). If a punitive God, most notably Satan, is on one's mind, then people behave more morally, presumably because they are afraid of punishment.

Maybe our intentions for doing "good" are not as virtuous as we often assume.



Subscribe to The Big Questions

Nathan Heflick completed his Ph.D. in social psychology at The University of South Florida.

more...