Saving Normal

Mental health and what is normal.

Two Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest

A cautionary tale of a stupid young doctor (me) who collaborated in the massive misdiagnosis and mistreatment of a teenage girl (Mindy Lewis). Read More

My tea leaves

I'm a little surprised that my friend, Allen, didn't mention the new genome study just released,corroborating my unifying Bipolar theory. Showing Bipolar genes overlapping with Schizophrenic genes.

Mindy is only half correct.

Latest Eugenics/Euthanasia Agenda Duly Noticed

Dear David P or Tea Leaves,

You are probably aware that psychiatry with aid from the robber barrons of their time invented the bogus, evil, predatory eugenics theories in the 1930's that unleashed the gassing to death of those they stigmatized as "mentally ill" and otherwise inferior that greatly influenced Hitler when writing Mein Kampf. Psychiatry then persuaded Hitler to expand their psychopathic predation by transferring their gassing apparatus to concentration camps to more effectively exploit and murder those they called "human vermin" and other so called medical terms like the bipolar and schizophrenia fraud fads later used to prey on all humanity for greed, power and sadism. Those who ran the Nuremberg Trials admitted that without psychiatry, the Holocaust probably would never have happened. See articles by Dr. Peter Breggin, the conscience of psychiatry since it doesn't have its own.

Here is one of many articles exposing the true evil agenda of falsely claiming that genes cause various diseases and bogus, voted in DSM stigmas now declared invalid junk science by even your chief, Dr. Thomas Insel, Head of NIMH. Of course, anyone who had done the slightest research has known for decades that the DSM is total evil fraud and pseudoscience invented to blame the victims while denying all social, environmental and other contexts of abuse related stress and trauma and other human inflicted evil while selling out to Big Pharma to push the latest lethal drugs on patent to make global billions at the cost of countless destroyed lives.

And here's another one:

Dr. Jay Joseph has also exposed the evil fraud and right wing oppressive, predatory agenda behind biopsychiatry's neverending search for The Missing Gene and The Gene Illusion along with many others.

Thus, you may wish to reconsider bragging about your great contribution to the latest monstrous eugenics/euthanasia ploys.

First step in the right direction

Mr Frances,

I was glad to hear you finally admit that,

"It was only later when I had gathered much greater experience in the wider world of psychiatry and life that I realized I was also hurting people and learning a lot of the wrong things"

This is a long way from your past unapologetic defense of psychiatry. My hope is that one day you'll recognize that the whole psychiatric enterprise is nothing but a huge lie with the dual purpose of helping governments with social control (like the Inquisition used to do) and Big Pharma make obscene amounts of money out of psychiatric drugs.

For now I am happy that you seem to be headed in the right direction.

It is never too late to undo a wrong

This comment of yours, while still finding the appropriate spin to still defend psychiatry, is a good step in the right direction.

I pray that God will give you strength to recognize, before you leave this world, that psychiatry is an unscientific quackery that destroys more lives than it helps.

Those injured by psychiatry are unrecognized and uncounted

With all due respect, Dr. Frances, neither you or anybody else knows how many people are injured by psychiatric treatment.

Even a ratio of hundreds to thousands, is such a significant rate of injury -- The FDA considers a 1% adverse effect rate as "common" -- that psychiatry, if it were to become a responsible medical specialty, would routinely review such injuries and make recommendations for improvements in clinical practice.

There are no such process improvement programs in place in psychiatry, in any academic program, hospital, or clinical setting.

Not only do the injured go uncounted, they go unrecognized. Clinical psychiatry has tremendous difficulty identifying adverse reactions. It's more likely that an injured patient gets an escalated psychiatric diagnosis than an acknowledgement of medical error.

For example, agitation, sleeplessness, or akathisia caused by antidepressants are often misdiagnosed as emergence of bipolar disorder, calling for even more harmful polypharmacy.

Clinical psychiatry is widely ignorant of techniques to taper people off psychiatric drugs and is apt to diagnose withdrawal symptoms as relapse or emergence of a new, exotic psychiatric disorder demanding strenuous treatment -- much to the detriment of the patient's wellbeing.

The high rate of misdiagnosis and mistreatment is well documented, most recently regarding psychiatrists prescribing antipsychotics for children and antidepressants in general

This cannot entirely be laid to prescribing by general practitioners.

As your own anecdote above demonstrates, psychiatric diagnosis and treatment is subject to fads that gain traction regardless of patient harm.

Your opinion that "those who have suffered damage from ill conceived and poorly delivered treatment and are understandably angry and eager to protect others from a similar fate" are an inconsequential minority dwarfed by those experiencing huge benefit from psychiatric treatment is grounded in hope rather than fact.

Please call for psychiatry to systematically study damage from psychiatric treatment and put processes in place to develop clinical recommendations reducing injury.

A common reality

Thank you Dr. Frances for this insightful post on one aspect that motivates your call for reform. For a short version of Mindy's Story. And thank you, those of you who are experiential experts, for yor lucid comments.

If the APAs were to collect and evaluate the stories of thousands of survivors they would find Mindy's experience is extraordinarily common.

Some people are followers--they can't resist the societal pressure of being labelled by authorities; they experience what I believe is called mortification--a death of a part of themselves--to accept the role given them of mentally ill.
Others, like Mindy, have the inner strength to resist and recover.

Back in the 1960s schizophrenia was indeed the diagnosis-du-jour. Thousands of Vietnam veterans were labelled schizophrenic just as today soldiers returning from Afghanistan and Iraq with brain injuries are being labelled borderline personality disorder. A LABEL IS NOT AN ILLNESS. And misdiagnosis needs correcting.

Gregory Bateson pointed out, years ago, that systems in nature are sustainable and adaptable because they are organized through homeostasis--a concept that is the basis of 1st semester physiology--and they have feedback systems. He recognized that human cultures function in much the same way. But when systems lose their feedback mechanisms we find what is happening in many institutions today--first it was the tobacco industry, decades ago; now it's seen on Wall Street in financiers and businessmen; in the pharmaceutical and insurance companies that have virtually hijacked doctors and hospitals both in physical and mental health. Also politicians. And the food-processing industry that denies that adding refined sugars to practically everything is the cause of the obesity/diabetes epidemic.
Such widespread systems failure calls out for reform--and only the mental health system can explain what is happening. But first it must heal itself.

J. Heller, in Catch-22, got away with criticising the military by using satire and the absurd. Gregory Bateson called it Double-Bind--(see also Paul Gibney (May, 2006)--The Double-Bind Theory: Still Crazy-Making After All These Years (about failures in the mental health system in Australia).
We have a choice of doing nothing. Or of moving in the direction of finding solutions.

Dr. Frances, you undermine your own argument re DSM-5

Dr. Frances, psychiatric survivors are your best allies in your campaign to reform the DSM.

The argument that the number of those injured by psychiatry is inconsequential relative to all the good psychiatry does undermines your own criticism of the DSM-5: That it will cause overdiagnosis and overprescription.

The existence of those injured by psychiatry PROVES your critique is valid and a real medical issue.

But if you argue that real-world injury from psychiatry is inconsequential now, what's the problem with more diagnosis and more prescription via the DSM-5?

Please join with us in recognizing, not dismissing, the extent of injury done by psychiatry now and the potential expansion of this endangerment wrought by the DSM-5.

Bravo, Altostrata! You've

Bravo, Altostrata!
You've challanged Dr. Frances in his contradictions--you're brief and right on target.
But does he read the feedback (and take it seriously into consideration)?

WHAT'S NEEDED is a SURVEY/vote among survivors of the mental "health" system--
Has psychiatric treatment helped or hindered your life?
Has it been confusing or a Catch-22 (we'll help you if you accept you can't get well)?
Have you restabilized--have you recovered--how much--and are you living a meaningful life?
Have meds helped--are there negative side effects--how bad?
What has helped more--doctors and counselors--or peer support?
Is emotional growth important to healing?

MH professionals need some honest feedback. (Not--Yes, thank you so much, doctor--please don't list me as a difficult patient or oppositional or dangerous).

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.

More information about formatting options

Allen Frances, M.D., was chair of the DSM-IV Task Force and is currently professor emeritus at Duke.


Subscribe to Saving Normal

Current Issue

Dreams of Glory

Daydreaming: How the best ideas emerge from the ether.