Routine Miracles

Restoring faith and hope in medicine.

The Negative Forces Opposing Healthcare Reform will not Disappear and it does not Matter

Voices that scream 'Repeal' are an auditory hallucination, not real.

The voices shouting "repeal and reverse" regarding healthcare reform are no more powerful than an auditory hallucination. I don't have a particular objection to taking an active stance and not taking things for granted, but with majorities in both the house and the senate, the likelihood of a reversal is pretty dim. Also, there is very little precedent for expanding social programs to the general public and then having them reversed.

It will also be pretty hard to "demonize" keeping your kid on health insurance until age 26, or preventing a for-profit insurance company from kicking grandma off her insurance for a pre-existing condition.

This is not exactly a "hot button" issue like gay marriage. Are there people opposed to these reforms? No. They are just opposed to paying for them. But even if these reforms increase the deficit, the "deficit" is a pretty abstract concept compared to, "I got my medicine today" or "I did not go bankrupt for health cost issues."

So, I say to the advocates of reform: Be Not Afraid. The voices that once screamed "Death Panel" and now scream "Repeal" are nothing more than an auditory hallucination. And like hallucinations to a schizophrenic, they are not pleasant, but they are not real either, and they can't hurt you.

In six months reforms will become practical in stages.

We will get our medications, and the scary voices will go away.



Subscribe to Routine Miracles

Conrad Fischer, M.D., is a specialist in Internal Medicine and is the Director of Educational Development at the Jamaica Hospital Medical Center in NYC.

more...