Rethinking Men

What masculinity means in the 21st century.

The Marlboro Man and the Old Spice Guy

The Old Spice guy has replaced the Marlboro Man

The Old Spice guy has replaced the Marlboro Man as the latest male icon. Following the appearance of the Old Spice ads, sales soared 107% in one month, from May 19 to June 19. (Are we gullible or what?)

What does this mean? Is this progress? Hard to tell. The MM was a hard-working cowboy, alone but not lonely. He had his horse, his cattle, his smokes and beautiful range lit up by magnificent sunsets. No women in sight. Peaceful. He would light his campfire, cook his grub and fix his coffee, plain fare, no chefs. No worries. He was a descendent of the old Wild West, but with no Colt on his hip and no rifle in its scabbard. This was the manly life: autonomous, self-reliant, self-sufficient, rural, natural, as prescribed by Emerson and Thoreau. He's a John Wayne type of guy (but less violent) who also died of lung cancer. Oh yes, and he's white.

In contrast, the OS guy is black, half-naked (upper, not lower), also good-looking, does not work, so far as we know; he is also alone, but lonely and all about sex, specifically, poaching your girl. So he is perhaps a sex addict. He is heavily reliant on gadgets and status symbols, (to bolster his self-image? Does he have an inferiority complex?) and evidently extremely wealthy, dribbling diamonds, (some say a girl's best friend,) and a bit of a joker, riding a horse backwards, so a bit of a show-off, a young George Clooney rather than John Wayne. He is muscular, so even if he does not work, he does work out--a gym rat. Two more advantages over the MM: he does not smoke, so this is definitely an asset; and he smells better, as he points out (so he is not modest nor self-deprecating, even if he is also correct). The MM presumably smells of cigarette smoke, wood smoke, sweat, cattle and dung: an intoxicating perhaps toxic aroma.

Find a Therapist

Search for a mental health professional near you.

Both men seem content, though the OS guy may have ADD -- he is a restless soul. So who do you want? Or which would you rather be? The MM is a traditional male fantasy; is the OS guy a male or a female fantasy? Or both?

I suspect, though I may be wrong (you think?) that most women would prefer the OS guy: n/s, smells good, wealthy, fit, sexy, ...what more would anyone want? (At last, the answer to Freud's old question.) But also, on the down side, he has no known source of income, perhaps has ADD and an inferiority complex, and he is narcissistic and a womanizer: I suspect that he would soon prefer the next woman...so make sure you get a pre-nup. And gentlemen: would you rather be a cowboy eating beans with your horse or a wealthy, muscular sex addict? It's a tough call.

But not that tough -- which is why the sales jumped after the showing of the ad. Not to boast, but I bought the product before the ads and think that the OS guy is actually modelled on the typical consumer: Me. He is in fact a dead ringer for me, except for the age, wealth, color, gadgets and muscles, but apart from that...



Subscribe to Rethinking Men

Anthony Synnott, Ph.D., is a professor of sociology at Concordia University in Montreal.

more...