In Practice

A Practicing Doctor's Views on Psychiatry and Contemporary Culture.
Peter D. Kramer is a psychiatrist and author. His books include Against Depression and Listening to Prozac. See full bio

Comments on "How Adversity Changes the Brain -- and Its Genes"

How Adversity Changes the Brain -- and Its Genes

How does adversity translate into depression? In particular, how does life experience make a person suicidal? This month, scientists opened a new window on mood disorder in the brain, using the tools of a discipline we have been tracking on this blog, epigenetics. The study shows causation in a direction that is only just becoming familiar: harmful experiences can give rise to harmful genetics. Read More

Left ,LEFT Big RIGHT-Depressions down again!

Your blog writings are most times technical jabs that soon follow through with knockout punches.I feel the full brunt force. Sincerely,David

Most of your posts are quite

Most of your posts are quite depressing. Has your research ever created uplifting results?

NPR

I see the fellow you discussed depression with on NPR has his own blog.I read it and fell asleep half way through. All that education and experience and such predictable thoughts. Sincerely,David

On the subject of uplifting

On the subject of uplifting results versus depressing ones:
Depression is a depressing subject by nature! Especially when you see really bad damage that ruins lives. But while I was reading through this post I had a mixture of feelings.

I was thinking of the damage I probably have sustained through traumatic events in my life, the genetics I inherited that may give me a higher risk of depression, and comparing that with other people I know. My mother's life was ruined by an intractable depression, and I am aware that I may be at risk. But now I read that tragic or stressful events cause physical, genetic changes as well. This makes me feel more like we all have these marks on our brains, some more, some less, but we can deal with them through therapy, medication, and other means. It feels to me like it's all a part of being human. It gives me a broader perspective. I find that uplifting, or at least, not depressing!

To Margy: did you also read

To Margy: did you also read that according to these men the damage is irreparable? That sounds pretty pessimistic to me!

There are scientists like Dr. Davidson* who believe the oppossite is true. That is much more uplifting! Their research is based on scientific evidence as well.

* http://psyphz.psych.wisc.edu/

Believe what you will at your peril

I've seen uplifting results in the chronically depressed when they take the brain saving,personality altering,ethics adhering medicine called Prozac. There's nothing more hopeful than knowing that depressed people may have a chance at another life opposed to the unethical and probably criminal life their leading.If you need a pep talk about depression go to Jim ( more pushups) Gordon's website.He will tell you all you want to here as your brain wastes away. Peter Kramer helps people,that other guy helps himself. Hope that wasn't too crabby. With fondness,David

Prozac does not change your

Prozac does not change your personality. Ethics adhering? What kind of ethics are you talking about? So you are saying depressed people are leading an unethical and criminal life?

Mike, didn't you know that

Mike,
didn't you know that David Petropoulos is Dr. Kramer's unpaid PR man, perhaps he get kickbacks such as free therapy?

Haha, that would explain his

Haha, that would explain his comments.

The someone buried down deep

If people with depression, don't have personality problems and ethical problems then there's no need to cure depression. Then do we let them rot? or should i say let you rot.I think your worth saving,especially with such a nice lexicon. Sincerely-David

oi vey David, please with

oi vey David,
please with the syntax.
it hurts to read!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options


Subscribe to In Practice

Be Who You Want, Have What You Want

The effective program that shows step-by-step how to create the life you want.
Read more...
Argosy University
Learn more about our graduate degree programs in clinical psychology.
Read more...
Anxiety Free
A comprehensive formula with herbs and nutrients clinically proven to increase feelings of well-being.
Read more...

Find a Therapist

Search our customized Directory for a licensed professional near you.

Current Issue

Everyday Creativity

How to start living creatively and reap the benefits.