Household Hazards

How Everyday Products Make Us Sick
Dr. Paul D. Blanc MD MSPH is Professor of Medicine and Endowed Chair in Occupational and Environmental Medicine at the University of California San Francisco. See full bio

Just when you thought it was safe to go to the playground again

Lead - an old, unwanted hazard that just wont go away.

In previous postings, I addressed emerging adverse health issues related to two metals: zinc and manganese. Lead, unlike those substances, is a hazard so well known and so widely recognized that most people reasonably assume the problem has long since been addressed. Lead in house paint, in ceramic glazes, in solder, in batteries - and especially in all the jobs that produce these everyday products - has been a key source of poisonings past. Sadly though, lead has been finding important novel forms in which to raise its specter anew. It's like the bad sequel to a grade-B horror film better not seen in the first place.

Lead is a toxic metal. It has no natural role in human biological functioning. This was clear even in antiquity, when a classic Roman architecture text argued that clay was preferable to lead for water pipes, because plumbers so obviously were made sick by their trade. Times change. The ideal landscape in the ancient world might have included a verdant garden, but ancient architects never foresaw the lead-laden green hue of artificial turf.

Lead-contaminated artificial turf was first reported more than a year ago, when the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) identified the problem, more or less by accident. Testing a playing field for possible lead contamination from a nearby factory, it was discovered that air pollution was not at issue, but that the green-grass color of the synthetic turf was thanks to a toxic pigment, lead chromate. Further sampling showed that this was standard in the nylon or nylon/polyethylene blends of synthetic turf that dominate the market. The CDC reassured the public that lead-contamination was only a potential problem for turf that was dusty, outdoors, and used a lot. The CDC did not hazard a guess as to how many of the athletic fields across the U.S.A. might fit this bill. For prevention, the CDC boldly suggested vigorous hand washing for children younger than six who played on ersatz lawns.

The CDC's inaction was followed up by a clean bill of health for leaded turf from the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). This is the same U.S. governmental agency that oversaw the importation of millions of lead-tainted toys over the last few years. AstroTurf, a major producer of the product, tells us, "We've partnered with other green companies to create products that are better for the environment" (http://www.astroturfusa.com/technology) and even promotes the installation of household AstroLawn to realize one's own personal field of dreams.

Now, following a year in which contamination levels have caused some localities to pull up existing synthetic fields and replace them with lead-free materials, new concerns have emerged regarding the recycled "tire crumb" frequently placed under such turf or used on its own as a recreation area covering. The regional Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) office in Denver has questioned the widespread use of such materials (http://www.denverpost.com/news/ci_12532547) because they might contain an array toxic chemicals to which children could be exposed.

Maybe the CDC, the CPSC, and the EPA should simply duke it out on the playground.

 



Subscribe to Household Hazards

Recent Posts in Household Hazards

Toxic waste abroad and at home
More worries from swine
Asthma-causing consumer products
Legal suit calls attention to lead in artifical turf

Find a Therapist

Search our customized Directory for a licensed professional near you.

Current Issue

Everyday Creativity

How to start living creatively and reap the benefits.