Grand Rounds

Why we do the things we do

Divergent Ain't So Divergent

The Allure of the Adolescent Dystopian Tale

Unless you live under a cinematic rock, you’ll notice that there are an awful lot of films lately that involve depressing dystopian landscapes, beautiful young people fighting those dystopian landscapes, and an altogether dismal view of our future. 

As a child psychiatrist and as a writer (indeed, as a writer who has published a dystopian novel) I am often asked to make sense of this trend. Isn’t the world spooky enough, parents ask? Why can’t our kids watch The Breakfast Club the way we did?

I of course have no monopoly on the one true answer to this query. People like the same thematic qualities for all sorts of different reasons, and it would be foolish to say that everyone seeks out the same stories for the same emotional purposes. I also know better than to dive into a political explanation for the popularity of this genre.

Find a Therapist

Search for a mental health professional near you.

However, I’d like to argue that there is a hidden grain of resiliency buried near the surface of the dour and cloudy plots that these movies bring us. Remember that the best fiction, and especially the best fantasy fiction, often show us how NOT to behave. In fact, usually the protagonists of these stories are embroiled in a noble fight against the reductionist formulas that dystopian worlds engender. In The Hunger Games, Katniss refuses to allow the Games to win. Lives are very personally at stake, and she finds a way, albeit a dangerous way, to circumvent the horrific system of control under which she is forced to live. In that sense, the classifications which totalitarian systems seem intent on creating and defining—and, while we’re at it, recall that ALL teens feel at times that their world is totalitarian—are overcome by the heroes of these stories as the heroes themselves break forth in glorious and unmistakable individualism. I’m not arguing that this is particularly new, either. The early 90s band Rage Against the Machine did not simply draw its name out of a hat…

To make the point that these stories speak especially to the developmental challenges of adolescence, let’s look at the most recent film to make major headlines. The movie Divergent opened last week to lackluster critical reviews but nevertheless stellar box office numbers. After it’s first weekend, Divergent made a reported 56 million dollars. That’s a clear win in Hollywood, and usually (though not always) this kind of win speaks to a coalescence of cultural zeitgeist with Hollywood ambitions. So, what’s going on with Divergent? Why is it such a hit?

Here’s the background: Divergent is based on Veronica Roth’s best-selling young adult novel of the same name. The story is set in a world (and no major spoilers here) in which a now partially ruined Chicago, presumably after some kind of intense and violent conflict, has managed to recreate civility by dividing people during adolescence into five distinct groups. Once you turn 16, rather than simply going on your first real date (as was the custom during MY adolescence), you are forced to choose whether you will be purely selfless, purely learned, purely brave, purely truthful, or purely peaceful. Once you choose, there is no room for change, and if you choose or are chosen to be a member of a different group from your parents, then you can never, ever go back to your parents.

Imagine, therefore, the stakes! You must be all one thing and no other thing. You must either utterly embrace or utterly reject your parents’ values. There is no middle ground, and in a turning of the tables that we see as markers of healthy society, a functional world in Divergent is kept safe by forcing extreme views among extreme factions. These factions then must come together as coherent groups to create an overall less extreme whole. In this way, societal balance is maintained through the deliberate sacrifice of the balanced individual.

And this, it turns out, is exactly the means by which middle school kids keep the peace in their own governing bodies. The school cafeteria and the after school milieu are defined, in middle school, by the group to which you belong. It’s what psychologist and Harvard Education School Professor Gil Noam calls “The Psychology of Belonging.”

Middle school kids sit in their groups—the band kids, the jocks, the goths, the cheerleaders, and so on—and they, together, represent the many opportunities and paths that are available to kids as they grow up. No reasonable adult expects them to stay within one group forever, but the kids themselves have a very hard time imagining changing allegiances or even embracing mixed allegiances, and one could argue that the job of parents and teachers it to help kids to have the confidence and courage to move among differing groups.

You can, after all, have green hair AND be on the wrestling team in 11th grade. It might not work so well when you’re 12, but if it doesn't work when you’re 16, you’re going to have a hard time transitioning to adulthood.

Herein lies the secret, I’d hazard, to the astounding success of all of these films. In the brutal displacement that dystopian and apocalyptic tales afford, we are able to grapple with the “what if” scenarios that speak to our most primitive wishes and fears with regard to growing up. If you are comfortable in your group, it can be scary to move among groups. And yet, if you refuse to move among groups, you soon find that the group where you thought you belonged has changed dramatically and is something new and increasingly unrecognizable. In other words, what works in 7th grade does not, by definition, work so well in 12th grade. This story line may seem dramatically mundane when compared to the ruined Chicago of Divergent or the scarred Appalachia of The Hunger Games, and yet these stories work well, perhaps even better, in these imagined and depressing landscapes. We can better tolerate the emotional darkness that societal prohibitions against change could create if we are told to picture these worlds in already broken places. 

To that end, these stories, like all good stories, are intensely allegorical. Kids love this stuff because the epic battles that that they see on the screen reflect for them their own epic struggles towards individualism.

From a developmental standpoint, these movies are ultimately optimistic. They remind the viewer that even the most restrictive and soul-robbing societies—in short order, the way many kids view middle school—can be tolerated, worked with, and ultimately overthrown. That’s a particularly hopeful view when you’re 12 years old and can’t ever imagine changing.   

And what about adults? Well, those feelings are closer to the surface than we might like to admit. That’s why these stories work for the parents as much as for their children.  

 

Steven Schlozman is the associate director of the Clay Center for Healthy Young Minds at Massachusetts General Hospital and the author of the novel The Zombie Autopsies.The Zombie Autopsies has been adapted for film by George Romero.

Steven Schlozman, M.D., is an Associate Director of Medical Student Education in Psychiatry for Harvard Medical School.

more...

Subscribe to Grand Rounds

Current Issue

Let It Go!

It can take a radical reboot to get past old hurts and injustices.