Grand Rounds

Why we do the things we do.

It's All About Control

I am a child shrink. The formal term is “child psychiatrist”, a title I relish because it leaves available the ambiguity of whether I treat young people or am in fact a child myself.  Like many things in psychiatry, the answer to this quandary is not always clear. What is clear, however, is that many shrinks like football.  I have no formal data with which to support this heartfelt assertion. Read More

Football

Dear Dr. Schlozman,

Football is life. My favorite player was Franco Harris. (Watch him on YouTube) My eye caught him in 1974 after being diagnosed with Rheumatoid Arthritis when any movement was almost impossible. Watching him struggle to the end zone gave me the courage to struggle to the bathroom. If he could do it, that is, carry the ball through the line, so could I. And I did.

Thanks for your post.
Carolyn Jenkins

Regarding Franco Harris

Thanks for your kind comments. I gotta say that you could not have picked a better guy than Franco Harris. He remains the one and only favorite first player that I ever read everything about. (How's that for a lousy sentence?) I remember his fluidity and his power, almost a cliche, the Ying and the Yang of Fullbacks who ran like a halfback when he had to. For a brief glorious 7th grade year my team called me "Franco" when it became clear that my early puberty made it possible for me to run people over with little skill but much imagined grandeur. More importantly, I am glad he gave you the strength you needed. I trust your RA is better. and that your love of the game and of life persists.

Best Regards

Steve Schlozman

Football

Thank-you for your reply. Yes, much has changed in the treatment of RA and I'm doing very well. I'm watching Buffalo and Miami play in Toronto right now. I live in the next city, Mississauga, ON so it's very exciting to have the NFL playing here.

All the best,
Carolyn Jenkins

Control

Dear Dr. Schlozman,

Thank you for that beautiful little excerpt. For people such as myself, who are intending on studying psychology, such articles are important for knowledge not so much obtained through books and in lectures. One needs experience as well.
It is very interesting to understand these basic rules of the brain, to put them into perspective, and use them on ourselves!
Personally, I am one to use the limbic part of my brain, in many everyday acts. You could look at this as confidence or simply pure nature, but either way, it is easy to see your logic and understanding in everyone's actions and thoughts.
If you ever write more, I'd love to hear your thoughts and articles.

Thank you again for enlightening me!

Sincerely,

Madison Fritzsche

the limbic imperative

thanks very much for your thoughts. We can't be human without being limbic - this is something it sounds like you understand pretty well. The really fun thing, I think, about being human, about having the opportunity to benefit from something as complex as our great big brains, is the way that these limbic moments naturally lend themselves to translation in higher cortical ways. I think this is why I was lauding and continue to laud football - not because it creates this constant tension in the way our neurobiology dictates our behavior, but because it represents in a codified fashion the means by which our neurobiology dictates our behavior. As someone else has commented above, football is life. Life didn't evolve to mimic football - we gravitate to the game because of the way it football evolved to show the best and the worst of us. Having just finished watching "The Longshots" with my 8 year old daughter, I fear I could go on all night. I will spare you this, and simply thank you for taking the time to comment. Best Regards, Steve Schlozman

hmmmmmm, but what does the

hmmmmmm, but what does the hight have to do with it?

Great post!

Very, very interesting. Thank you.... I might just be able to appreciate football now :)

go watch a game!

Thanks for giving the game a shot!
In the movie "the Longshots," admittedly a corny and predictable flick, the first girl quaterback in Little League football history leads her down-and-out team to fame and triumph. When they start winning they do all sorts of crazy dances and celebrative moves in the endzone - break dancing, acrobatics, high and low fives burst out like thunderstorms. Then the head coach (played by Ice Cube, who, by the way, does a great job) shows them his endzone dance. He has one of the players act like a referee and he hands the "ref" the ball and says thanks. "Act like you been there before," he instructs, and the kids on the team are quiet and contemplative. That's what I watch for in a game. (Plus, check out the highlights of Pittsburgh-Dallas finish on last Sunday. Their brains were working overtime!)

what book?

what book?

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.

More information about formatting options

Subscribe to Grand Rounds

Steven Schlozman, M.D., is an Associate Director of Medical Student Education in Psychiatry for Harvard Medical School.

more...