Finding Your Voice

Insights into creative expression, for everyone on the stage of life.

Our Brothers' Keepers

Making the shift from cognitive dissonance to compassionate congruence

Yesterday, my partner and I were returning to our apartment after a walk in Central Park. It was a beautiful Saturday afternoon, and we were looking forward to a great evening with friends... I was off to see a Broadway play; John was heading out to dinner. We were running a bit late and in the process of calculating how to best get in and out the door in the time we had.

Then time stopped.

Turning onto our block, we saw a man clutching the railing and shaking violently. We joined a neighbor already with him, helping to steady him while a phone call was made to 911. It turned out the man had just been discharged from the hospital down the street, told he was fine, and to go home.

But he wasn't fine. And he had no home.

In the space of the next 45 minutes, we managed to get Tim- who couldn't walk- onto a luggage dolly, down the block, and checked back into the hospital. Also in the space of those 45 minutes, we witnessed human beings being anything but humane and counseling us to do the same. Two hospital security staff, the head nurse, and a patient in the waiting room all voiced- in front of Tim- that we shouldn't get attached or waste our time. The verbal and visual shaming were unbearable, even as a bystander.

I'm not writing to make anyone or anything wrong, or to discuss the current state of health care. I'm writing to share the experience of being with Tim yesterday, and the impact and implications for John and me... and for all of us.

It wasn't just the hospital staff that broke our hearts. It was both the disregard and looks of passerby on the street as we were with Tim. It was in the gasps and wild eyes of people seeing my arm around him. It was the man who begrudgingly gave us the luggage dolly without even glancing at Tim, and his calling after us wheeling a sick, shaking man to the hospital "just make sure to get the dolly back!"

There is so much pain in the world. To stop and consider it all would invite such a heartbreak that we wouldn't be able to go about our daily lives. So piece by piece, little by little, we turn down the volume on and vision of its evidence so that we can go about our normal routines.

But how 'normal' is a routine that literally walks by a man collapsing onto a sidewalk, or another man sleeping on one? How 'normal' is justifying and rationalizing that 'that's just the way it is' when we see our fellow man in need and won't even acknowledge his existence?

Our minds, by design, present reasons and excuses why things are ok the way they are. Cognitive dissonance requires us to make a choice: to see the world as generally fine so that we can be fine within it, or to acknowledge that it is not and necessarily be propelled into action. We so often choose the former so as not to have to deal with the latter.

John and I took our experience as an opportunity to look into our hearts and at our lives and ask ourselves whether the commitments we currently have are working... for us, for our families, for our communities, for our world. And the answer we came up with is no. Things are not fine when we ignore other human beings in large and little ways.  And we got present to how often we do it.

It is just not OK. And we're making some changes.



Subscribe to Finding Your Voice

Jennifer Hamady specializes in emotional issues that interfere with optimal self-expression and is the author of The Art of Singing, heralded as a breakthrough in the psychology of musical and personal performance.

more...