Domestic Intelligence

From surly teens to tough mothers-in-law, how to understand what's going on in your family.
Dr. Terri Apter is Senior Tutor at Newnham College, University of Cambridge. Her most recent book is The Sister Knot (2007). Her personal website is terriapter.com. See full bio

Comments on "Mother-Daughter Envy: Truth or Fable?"

Mother-Daughter Envy: Truth or Fable?

During the past month, I've been phoned several times by several different journalists keen to write a feature on mother/daughter envy. "Why are mothers envious of their daughters?" I am asked. Read More

mothers and daughters

I think the issue of envy occurs when the mother has some unresolved desires/ unattained personal goals, or depression in her own marriage, and the feeling of powerlessness to address these marital problems.
I think that if a mother has led somewhat of a fulfilling life, and believes in the process of her own ongoing spiritual and psychological evolution, then there is no need to envy anyone, especially your own daughter. Of course there are times when our happiness for someone else has traces of envy, especially if we are feeling particularly vulnerable that day or that week, or if we have suffered one too many losses in the recent past.
I have always worked hard at conquering my own feelings of envy, because I feel envy is generally an unproductive emotion, unless I am using those feelings to figure out what is lacking in my life. To feel envy, implies that we are somewhat less happy for our daughter than is possible. I think that I genuinely and thoroughly enjoy other peoples happiness, knowing that happiness is often times fleeting.I think I also can feel happiness for others(with the absence of envy)because I have confidence that I can generate my own happiness, if not now, then tomorrow.

MY WORK MISUNDERSTOOD IN YOUR BLOG

Dear Dr. Terri Apter:

Greetings! As you may know, I am a psychologist and the author of many books, including Women and Madness (1972) and Woman's Inhumanity to Women (2002) which contains three chapters about the mother-daughter relationship.

I am writing because you seem to have misunderstood and even reversed what I wrote in Salon about mother-daughter envy. My point was, sadly, quite opposite from the subject of your article. In my instance, the daughter, Rebecca Walker, seems to have based an entire career on criticizing and shaming her mother, the great, and greatly talented, Alice Walker. Indeed, like some other historical daughter figures, which is what I wrote about in my article at Salon, Rebecca has embraced more traditional views and castigates her mother for not sharing them. The mother remains silent. It is true, that many mothers also envy their daughters' youth, sexuality, ambition, and freedom. I have written about this. But not in the context of the unfortunate and one-sided Walker feud.

Sincerely yours,
Dr. Phyllis Chesler

Difference of opinion, not misunderstanding

Dear Dr Chesler I welcome your response and the opportunity to clarify my reference to your piece in Salon. Very specifically I say that you are referring to Rebecca Walker’s experience of her mother’s envy. This has led several journalists to contact me with queries about mother’s envy of a daughter, which, as you say, you have written about elsewhere. As I said in my blog, I do not agree that this is a common occurrence. So, we disagree, but there is no misunderstanding. Terri Apter

Dear Dr. Terri: Are you

Dear Dr. Terri:

Are you saying that maternal envy is uncommon and that I believe it is common? If so, you are right, and we will agree to disagree about this. I urge you to read my three chapters in Woman's Inhumanity to Woman on the subject and to be on the lookout for a brilliant dissertation underway by psychotherapist Mara Applebaum. This is such an important subject! Glad you are writing about it.

All best,
Dr. Phyllis

Desperate mum

My mum; everytime I be myself with my OWN opinions, I get a vibe from her, this vib telling me that he's depressed becuse I'm seemily, not like HER. She dosn't think about anything, to have an opinion. he i mentaly handycapped, I think so. Thn if I show som vonrability, she's ine, she's on top ofthe world lol. thought it was just soemthing to do with HER.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options


Subscribe to Domestic Intelligence

The Favorite Child

Discover how being the favorite child can confer both great advantages and significant emotional handicaps.
Read more...
Saybrook University
Pursue advanced degrees in Mind-Body Medicine and Psychology. Learn more.
Read more...
Kyolic Formula 109
Kyolic Formula 109 promotes healthy blood pressure and reduces stress by supporting relaxing.
Read more...

Find a Therapist

Search our customized Directory for a licensed professional near you.

Current Issue

Everyday Creativity

How to start living creatively and reap the benefits.