Curing the Healthcare Crisis

Empowering patients and caregivers

It’s Third-Party Payers, Stupid

To get costs under control, empower the consumer

How can you write an entire column about waste in health care and never mention why there is waste? Uwe Reinhardt shows he’s up to the task at the New York Times economics blog. Maybe it’s that bottle of champagne he mentioned the other day.

Are there huge administrative costs in the market for cosmetic surgery? Not that I’m aware of. How about Lasik surgery? What about walk in clinics? Domestic medical tourism? I don’t think so.

Even with third-party payers, waste suddenly vanishes if they empower patients and get out of the way. It took all of two years for WellPoint’s cost of joint replacements at out-of-network California hospitals to almost match the in-network cost after WellPoint made patients responsible for the extra payments.

Think about that. WellPoint didn’t have to negotiate a fee with anyone. No arguing or hassling over the charge for an aspirin — or any other charge. Just patients explaining to the admissions office that they only had so much money to spend. (That’s almost as effective as global budgets and price controls without all of the unintended bad consequences!)

Find a Therapist

Search for a mental health professional near you.

Is there waste in the Canadian health care system? Of course there is. It’s in the form of delayed surgeries. Cancelled surgeries. Even unnecessary surgeries. The cost of that kind of waste typically eludes the accountants however. That’s because the cost is born by the patients.

[Cross-posted at John Goodman's Health Policy Blog]

John C. Goodman, Ph.D. is Research Fellow at The Independent Institute; President in National Center for Policy Analysis, & author of Priceless: Curing the Healthcare Crisis.

more...

Subscribe to Curing the Healthcare Crisis

Current Issue

Dreams of Glory

Daydreaming: How the best ideas emerge from the ether.