Compulsive Acts

A psychiatrist's tales of ritual and obsession.

Googling Your Medical Record

Patients are telling their doctors, "please don’t type this in!”

Our clinic recently moved to a new charting system whereby medical notes are no longer handwritten. Instead, doctors and therapists now type their notes into a, we are abundantly assured, very secure database. The idea is to make records more easily accessible to other providers and to help make one’s medical history more “portable.” Plus, doctors’ legendarily bad handwriting no longer need get in the way of understanding what they are actually writing. We are hardly the first institution to adopt electronic medical records, and it seems as though whatever reformed health care system eventually emerges, it is sure to require some form of electronic charting as a way to promote efficiency, save trees, and enhance portability.

A few weeks into this experiment, some interesting unintended consequences are becoming obvious. While a session used to involve paying close attention to the patient’s expressions, and looking him or her straight in the eye in a way that builds rapport and communicates empathy, many of us now have to stare at our computer screens, instead, fingers on the keyboard as we type the information we are receiving. (This is much worse if the doctor never learned how to type.) As a result, the patient can feel ignored or experience the therapist as uninterested or un-warm, and the therapist may miss important facial cues or other telling body language.

Another consequence is patients clamming up. “You have zero privacy anyway. Get over it,” Scott McNeally, chief executive officer of Sun Microsystems, reportedly said in 1999. His somewhat insensitive remark has proven prescient. Ten years later, anyone can immediately locate your address, date of birth and phone number free of charge on Zabasearch.com. For $39.95, her or she can get a full “background check” on you, which includes a statewide criminal check, bankruptcies and liens attached to your name, small claims and judgments made against you, your home value, your aliases, your neighbors’ and relatives’ names, and, as the website promises, “much more.” Patients are increasingly worried that their medical data will have the same level of protection that their other identifying information enjoys... They understand how difficult it would be to reclaim something personal once it has leaked into cyberpace, and, as a result, some are withholding important information from their doctors or quickly following it with a “but please don’t type this in!” This was rather rare in the days of the paper chart. Health care consumers, like everybody else online, know that we live in a post-privacy age. However, unlike their privacy on Facebook, they can’t just “get over it.” And neither should they.



Subscribe to Compulsive Acts

Dr. Aboujaoude is a psychiatrist and author based at Stanford University. His most recent book is Virtually You: The Dangerous Powers of the E-Personality.

more...