Comfort Cravings

How to soothe yourself without food—and how to eat healthfully and mindfully

Forks Over Knives: Could This Movie Save Your Life?

Forks Over Knives: Could This Movie Save Your Life?

I'm officially adding another movie to my list of films that can help you to become a more mindful eater (see previous blog article).  It's a documentary called Forks Over Knives that was recently released in NYC, LA and various other cities. You may have seen a clip of it on the Dr. Oz T.V. show.  In a nutshell, Forks Over Knives is about two doctors, Dr. T. Colin Campbell and Dr. Esselstyn, who are advocating a plant based diet (similar to vegan). Whether you agree or totally disagree with the message of this movie, it may get you to start thinking critically about what you eat and how it impacts your health.

I invited a tough critic to review this film with me.  Let's just call him "John."  John is extremely attached to his BBQ grill, owns his own meat smoker and is an amateur connoisseur of steak.  I knew if there was going to be a tough sell, this man would be it.  Giving up meat, or any food for that matter, is the last thing on his mind.

See All Stories In

Feed Your Brain!

How you chow affects mood, memory, sleepiness—and even whether you can crack a good joke.

Find a Therapist

Search for a mental health professional near you.

I was prepared for the film's provocative message. I had the good fortune of meeting Dr. Esselstyn in person. For my work, I attended one of the lectures he gives across the country about his research and book.

The film, Forks Over Knives, is filled with statistics and research. The information they present suggests that what you eat, particularly the amount of protein, dairy, and oil, dramatically impacts your health. Critics of this approach indicate that the research may be presenting one side of the debate and is skewed. It's always important to look at research critically.  There is another problem that was not mentioned in the movie but is a real concern for those who treat eating disorders.  For some people, diets that restrict particular types of foods or food groups can lead people to become obsessive.  This can trigger disordered eating and eating disorders. 

This movie indicates that a plant based diet can decrease your risk of cancer significantly can get you off all kinds of medications.  A famous advocate of eating this way, Bill Clinton, among many others (click to see video).  This is not a new idea. As Hippocrates, the father of medicine, said in 460 BC, "Let food be thy medicine."  These doctors indicated that 70-80 percent of the health care budget could be reduced simply by changing the way we eat.

Unfortunately, documentaries are often seen by a select group.  It's likely that you would decide to see this film if you were already interested in the topic.  Therefore, these movie goers are probably already open to the idea of improving their eating habits.  The message needs to spread farther than this group.

If national change is to happen to our diet, we have to get people talking about it.  Here is my idea.  Turn this film into a Hollywood film. Cast a young Dr. Campbell as a Hollywood actor (Greg Kinnear or Matt Damon perhaps?) and tell his story. The documentary stated that Dr. Campbell allegedly was blackballed from Cornell for his ideas and research that went counter to many of the school's food industry ties.  Let both sides tell their version of the story.  Would it be controversial?  Definitely.  But, would this get us finally talking about what we eat in a new way?  Stop the diet talk and start talking about health.  Let's put it up for debate.

What did John, the meat eater, think of the film? "I never thought of it this way," he said as the movie ended.  He wasn't ready to give up meat and dairy but was sold on being more attentive and mindful of what he eats. He was impressed that these two doctors in their seventies were running, biking and looking great. John was still thinking about the movie the next day.  He reported ordering spinach in his omelet instead of bacon.

There are lots of different ways to eat to improve your health.  A plant based diet is just one approach. Be sure to examine the pros and cons of your eating plan with your doctor to see what works for you.  What is ultimately important is the overall message: it is time to begin to be more mindful of what, why and how you are eating for your health and well-being.

*To Learn More

Susan Albers @2011 www.eatingmindfully.com author of 50 Ways to Soothe Yourself Without Food.

 

 

Susan Albers, Psy.D., is a psychologist who specializes in eating issues, weight loss, body image concerns and mindfulness. 

more...

Subscribe to Comfort Cravings

Current Issue

Dreams of Glory

Daydreaming: How the best ideas emerge from the ether.