Addiction in Society

Addiction—the thematic malady for our society—entails every type of psychological and societal problem.

The Globalization of Psychiatry - Universalizing Our Mental Illness

Cross-cultural applicability research shows that DSM-IV-type emotional disorders are specific to the United States and the West.  As we enlighten the world about our "scientific" findings in psychiatry, we are instead creating a contagion of our mental illnesses around the world. Read More

What an excellent piece! It's

What an excellent piece! It's been about a half century since Szasz's Myth of Mental Illness (written more from a philosophical and libertarian point of view than a cross-cultural one), but the DSM continues to increase the number of diagnoses and to spread them around the world.

Don't Forget The Children

Nitwit child psychiatrist Joan Luby utilized a nifty hand puppet schtick to determine that 50% of all kids have significant psychiatric disorders:

http://www.health24.com/news/Depression/1-903,51967.asp

She should take her hand puppets to a psychiatrist cocktail party. The diagnostic results would no doubt be unanimously pathological.

P.S. Peter Kramer could hand out canapes topped with psycho-pharm sprinkles. He sort of looks like a waiter...

This is my kind of comment

How about if we hang Kramer in effigy from a loop of anti-depressants melted and fused together? To paraphrase Robert Mitchum in "Out of the Past," "I wonder if he'll ever know what a bad guy he really was."

Growth industry?

I was informed a few years ago that the mental health profession was one of the 'growth industries'. Could this be one of the reasons?

Mental Illness

Calling things an illness rather than the human condition has several advantages.
1) There is a new niche for writers, researchers, therapists to make
make a few more bucks
2) More laws can be passed to create another protected class
3) More bureaucrats can be hired to regulate this new protected class
4) More lawyers can be hired to defend this protected class whenever
unfairly discriminated.
5) Drug companies have new customers (people with mental illness)
6) Marketing people have new customers (drug companies)

Working on the human condition through the many techniques of self awareness however has a lot less economic and ego advantages.

STANTON

SO YOU'RE KELLY CASH!!!!

Well how do you like that!?!?

You certainly had me fooled...

...and after all the notes we exchanged on my site and after all my wet dreams....

Steve

interesting

interesting...i write my little rant on your page(twice!) and then i go type in "addiction is not a disease" at my favorite search engine and "Stanton Peele" is the first thing to come up. So here's number 3:

I say thank you, kind sir.

As a child and later as an adult I have been blessed with an undying curiosity. This has led me to question everything and anything. This also led to a great distaste of bullshit, whether on my tongue because it is being fed to me or because I am about to speak it. I do not question any particular side, but all sides, even my own.

This combined with the last several years of my young life spent abusing opiates has led me to become in awe of my nation's view of drug abuse-whether a legal view, or moral, cultural, etc. I keep being told that I have a disease. “Dis-ease,” as in, “not at ease?” Why, yes, I am not at ease with the situation. But “disease” as we have come to define it, I find that to be bullshit.

First, I KNOW that most of my problems with opiates are because they cost so incredibly much, why else does methadone work? Amazingly, being addicted physically and mentally is really not much of a problem if the drugs can be afforded. If it were a disease, being physically and mentally addicted alone would cause the problems. Most of the problems in my life with drugs are related to the drugs costing so much (or having to spend all my time and resources in the pursuit of happiness...err, drugs.)

When someone is ill-content, trying to find a path to their contentation is actually quiet normal; any thought otherwise is (AHEM!) ill-conceived. Again, it is the repercussions of the method chosen to achieve happiness (because of the way things are set up) that is the real problem. Touching on a sociological side to this debate is that it is most often best when one is able to make a living off of the things in life that give them a purpose, great satisfaction, or happiness. Having something that does this greatly reduces potential for drug abuse. If you ask any person who uses drugs too much, they will tell you that when they are working or busy they tend to use drugs less often. This demonstrates the aspect that drug abuse is not a disease, rather a symptom of a greater problem. When working, or busy, the reason for this lapse of abuse is that temporary satisfaction, or temporarily a thing that makes us happy, has been found. People commonly ask, "What do you do?" And when unable to reply, "Oh, I am an ironworker, or a nutritionist, etc..." those people are truly the at-risk. As a child I knew I was not actively in pursuit of my definition. End result being I do not feel satisfied in life or am not able to be happy through normal means (things that do not provide a jolt of happiness, but make one happy in small yet consistent amounts over time.) I have used drugs because they work to get happy and I have been longing for happy for a long time. Basically, what I am getting at is when someone does not build life around the things that make them happy; when they find drugs make them feel happy, most likely they keep using drugs. To me this says drug abuse is not so much the problem itself, but a perfectly normal response to a real underlying problem which is the real disease.

Now I am not a doctor, ironworker or nutritionist, but I find my stance unique enough to skeptically view the spectacle that is my nation’s drug abuse. Please if you need information or anything that can't be found but from someone like me, please contact me at "qrlos@yahoo.com". Anything I could do to help change things which would help not only myself but many others would be most satisfactory. For the only other way I have been harmed more than by my own hand ‘depends on drug policy, cultural and otherwise.’

response to Magnus

I think there is merit in what you say. I believe in time- science will be able to demonstrate reproducible studies to that or to a similar effect. Metabolic processes and the consequences of their dysfunction at a cellular level are beyond interesting. Real progress rarely explodes onto the scene, anyway.
Don't despair with this. There is research being done that will interconnect disciplines. Things are slowly happening that will be to the betterment of us. I'm sure Dr. Peele would be overjoyed to have strides made in any area of the mind/body part of the human condition.
btw...a great deal of trimming has been done to this section. Its always fun to see psychologists enjoying their work.

misrepresentation

Did you actually read the book? I find that you lack any of the nuance presented therein.

It also seems that you lack a basic foundation in understanding brain disorders that are going undiagnosed and untreated in many non-U.S. countries -- with tragic fallout. (Even in the U.S., vast numbers of people are going without treatment and instead are ending up in jail or otherwise languishing.)

I receive mail from all over the world, asking for help in finding local treatment for something as "simple" as ADHD -- a condition that's been well-studied for the past 50 years and for which we have effective treatments. Typically, unless the person has money and can travel to the U.S. or another medically advanced country, there is no hope for them.

Your perspective strikes me as utterly lacking in compassion and empathy.

All over the world!

Not being treated for ADHD - it's a sin and a travesty. And Ibet a lot of Haitians aren't being treated for anorexia. And people in Darfur for depression. Here's my idea - let's start a group - instead of dropping food and trying to end wars, will drop in Concerta and Zoloft! What do you say?

I FORBID you to read any of my blogs! (Did you see Peter Gray's recent one about the monumental jump in depression among young people in the U.S.? If only we can get to the rest of the world, they'll be as depressed as we are - compassionate depression I call it.

Yes, you wouldn't know

Yes, you wouldn't know anything about it, obviously, but it is a sin and a travesty that people with ADHD who want treatment can't get it, not only due to finances but due to lingering and vainglorious ignorance.

And if you think people who perpetuate the tragedies of Darfur and Haiti -- or go off on jihad or killing abortion doctors -- are mentally healthy, then you are blind. The world is burdened with mental illness, and we are just on the verge of understanding it and finding ways to mitigate it.

It seems that PT is specializing now in fringe anti-science "psychologists" who lack any other platform. What a waste of space.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.

More information about formatting options

Subscribe to Addiction in Society

Stanton Peele, Ph.D., J.D., has been researching and treating addiction since he wrote Love and Addiction (1975). He also wrote 7 Tools to Beat Addiction.

more...