The flip side of disaster

Though it may be difficult for the survivor of a plane crash or mass shootingto "look on the bright side," it appears that those who do actually recover best grow the most as a result of the tragedy.

Researchers at Washington University in St. Louis interviewed the survivors of three traumatic events--a tornado, a plane crash, and a mass shooting--a few weeks and then three years after they occurred. Those survivors who could find something good that came out of the experience soon after it happened--" I realized how much I loved my family," for example, or "I decided that life was too short not to follow my dreams"--had made a better recovery at the time of the follow-up interview.

People who felt they were going to die during the disaster were especially likely to report personal growth as a result of the experience. Surprisingly, so were people who'd had many prior mental health problems.

"Those whose lives are in the worst shape may have the most to gain from adverse J. Curtis McMillen, Ph.D., lead author of the study. "They can use a traumatic event to reorganize their lives." He also notes that inhabitants of small towns tended to do better than those who lived in big cities, perhaps because of the social and material support such towns could offer.

McMillen says the "perceived benefit" concept might be used to develop interventions for survivors of tragedies, including support groups, peer counselling, writing exercises, and individual therapy. But those who would help survivors see the positive side of their ordeal must be sensitive in their efforts, he warns: pushing people to see benefit in tragedy may hamper their recovery if it's done too soon.

A.M.P.

Tags: disaster, inhabitants, interventions, j curtis, material support, mcmillen, mental health problems, ordeal, personal growth, plane crash, recovery, support groups, Survivor, survivors, tornado, tragedies, tragedy, trauma, traumatic event, traumatic events, washington university in st louis, writing exercises

Current Issue

Everyday Creativity

How to start living creatively and reap the benefits.

Find a Therapist

Search our customized Directory for a licensed professional near you.