Who Knocks Shocks?

Medical procedures are a lot like, say, hip-huggers. They catch on in some places more than others. But what's the most variably used procedure of all?

The answer is ECT--electroconvulsive therapy. As many as 100,000 people receive ECT each year. But a nationwide survey of psychiatrists indicates that ECT--once known as "shock therapy"--isn't used at all in a third of American cities. And that's robbing us of the most effective treatment around for severe depression that won't respond to medication, says Harvard psychiatrist Richard Hermann, M.D.

ECT has gotten a bad rap, Hermann insists. Those horrifying scenes in One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest raise the specter of electric shocks administered to punish the helpless denizens of run-down institutions. But this is not your father's ECT: Today the procedure is given most often to middle- and upper-class patients in classy, rigorously monitored private facilities, report Hermann, Robert Dorwart, M.D., and colleagues.

Why the variability in ECT use? Overly strict state regulations for one thing, contends Hermann. Well-meaning politicians in many states imposed rules that limit its use, particularly in public hospitals. But Hermann thinks legislators might reconsider if they realized how safe and effective ECT is: "To see a patient who thought about nothing but suicide for months regain himself after ECT is extraordinary."

Tags: american cities, bad rap, cuckoo, denizens, depression, electric shocks, electro convulsive therapy, electroconvulsive Therapy, harvard psychiatrist, legislators, medical procedures, one flew over the cuckoo s nest, public hospitals, regulation, severe depression, shock therapy, specter, treatment, variability, well meaning

Current Issue

Everyday Creativity

How to start living creatively and reap the benefits.

Find a Therapist

Search our customized Directory for a licensed professional near you.
Be Who You Want, Have What You Want

The effective program that shows step-by-step how to create the life you want.
Read more...
Add Lib capsules libido enhancement
Add Lib puts you in the mood for romance. Ignite passion and desire in 24 hours or less.
Read more...
Kyolic Formula 109
Kyolic Formula 109 promotes healthy blood pressure and reduces stress by supporting relaxing.
Read more...