When words don't fail

'Bill" has an IQ of 49, a score exports label "moderate mentalretardation." Yet when asked to describe an elephant, Bill's answer is complex, almost poetic: "It has long gray ears, fan ears, ears that can blow in the wind."

Bill's articulate response isn't unusual--for people with Williams syndrome, a rare genetic disorder that causes retardation yet leaves language and social skills strangely unscathed. But Williams syndrome is more than a neurological curiosity. The disorder may reveal surprising clues to how our brains are organized,says Ursula Bellugi, director of the Salk Institute's Cognitive Neuroscience lab.

Discovered only in 1961, Williams syndrome (WS) afflicts about one in 25,000 children in the U.S. In a sense the syndrome is the opposite of autism: Those who have it are social savants. While autistic kids often seem to inhabit a private universe, oblivious to the thoughts and feelings of others, people with WS "are social to the extent that parents have to stop them from talking to strangers," Bellugi says. So friendly and well-spoken are they that some wags refer to the Condition as "cocktail-party syndrome."

The language skills of WS subjects far exceed those of others with the same IQ--and may surpass even normal controls. A sampling:

o People with Williams syndrome pick up new and unusual words with ease. Asked to name as many animals as they can in 60 seconds, WS subjects typically come up with as many responses as normal controls--and they're more likely to name uncommon animals like weasel or yak.

o They have no trouble grasping unconventional sentence structures, like passive voice, that overwhelm people with Down's syndrome and other forms of retardation.

o Natural storytellers, they pepper their tales with sound effects and with audience hookers like guess what happened next and lo and behold!

How do these islands of intact skills survive? The neural circuitry that controls them may be distinct from the rest of the brain, isolated in a "social module," Bellugi and her colleagues argue in the Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience (Vol. 7, No. 2). If so, language and social interaction skills may actually be hardwired into our brains.

Those behaviors are controlled by the frontal cortex and neocerebellum, regions that "have greatly enlarged in the change from primate to man," notes Bellugi. It is those brain areas that, in effect, separate us from lower animals. So our superior language skills aren't simply an outgrowth of our intelligence, but may actually be the essence of what makes us human.

PHOTO (COLOR): A boy.

Tags: autistic kids, brain, cocktail party, language, language skills, passive voice, rare genetic disorder, salk institute, savants, social, storytellers, talking to strangers, thoughts and feelings, unusual words, wags, weasel, Williams Syndrome

Current Issue

Are You with the Right Mate?

It is natural to wonder if your partner is the right one for you.