Short comings, nice guys, and grandmas

Instead of sending D. the careful, self-deprecating letter you wrote him, send him the straight, desperate letter you wrote me. You can't marry someone with whom you must be that cautious, someone you firmly believe would be bored by your thoughts and feelings, or someone who bores you so much it drains the life out of you.

D. surely knows there's a problem, and he may be even more afraid than you are of the necessary conflict of a relationship. D. may be trying to handle the deadness in the relationship by minimizing and avoiding the problems you see. He may naively believe that he can make a marriage work by solving problems or avoiding them, when actually marriage is a lifetime process of dealing with them by comparing your reactions to the enlightening messiness of life.

You mustn't marry people just because they are nice guys. I'm glad D. doesn't lie, cheat, or beat you, but that isn't enough to make a guy a good first husband. (I know some tired, bruised women would choose just such virtues in a third husband.) Many a woman will stick with a man who does lie, cheat, and beat her because he has the overriding virtue of caring about his and her emotional lives.

D. needs to learn a new language. If he is too afraid of clinical problem-solving, a group setting may be less threatening. Churches and mental health centers often offer free or inexpensive quasi-clinical communication courses for couples. Take him to class where they will teach him the language of life and emotions. Don't be ashamed of it: go on and speak it yourself. Read books together; go to movies about something more emotionally complex than broken glass and car crashes. Refuse to live at his emotional level.

Break it off if you like. Breaking off a relationship at this stage (before children) is nothing to feel guilty about. For his sake as well as for your own, stop protecting him from knowing he's alive and learning to talk about it.

Everyone--even an emotionally silent man--deserves a marriage partner he or she can please. He may pull back from the life you offer him now, but he'll need to catch on eventually--there are not enough emotionally deaf women to go around for all the emotionally dumb men out there. In time, any woman will want a response.

And please stop apologizing to him for not being happy. Until he cares how you feel and tells you how he feels, there is nothing between you to be happy about.

Dear Dr, Frank,

My 24-year-old daughter crashed emotionally at the age of 14 and has called herself "Mouse" since then. For seven years she has been with a man of a different race and culture. They have an 18-month-old son together. She drives a truck and leaves my grandson with his father, who has never held a job, drinks beer, and gets money from his gambling buddies.

Recently, I noticed that the baby's tongue and lower lip were swollen. He was acting out a lot of anger by hitting things. My daughter said, "His father wouldn't hurt him. He takes good care of him." I believe my fear is justified. The father is unfit to be a parent and my daughter is unfit for leaving the child with him.

But the Arizona Child Protective Service has been written up in the newspaper because their foster care system has generated 10 deaths in two years and there is high turnover of management. I cannot bring myself to feed my grandson to a system that is impersonal and has received so much bad publicity. I want the child with me, but my daughter doesn't believe he is in jeopardy, though he is sick with a cold most of the time and survives on soda pop and junk food.

Is there any option other than reporting the situation to a system that wouldn't care about my grandson?

-- Mouse's Mom

Dear Grandmouse,

I know you're not pleased with how your daughter's life is going. She's taken a rough road. But she dearly considers herself lucky to have this man as a partner and father to her son. He seems to give her the opportunity to develop her own competence. Incompetent men are useful if they inspire mousy women to roar. And ordinarily, I can think of nothing more ideal for a little boy than to be raised at home by his domesticated, underwhelming father.

I understand your concern if the child's father is drinking on the job. Parenting is too important to be done by people who are rendering themselves brain damaged as they do it.

But even so, you just don't describe anything in your letter that would warrant Child Protective intervention. Toddlers fall and hurt their lips routinely. Of course, if there is more than you have told me, or if you have any doubts, call Protective Services and talk it over with them. If then the time comes when the child is more clearly in danger, they will already have been alerted.

You know that a child is going to get more love and more personal attention with his or her own family than in an institution or a foster setting. Still, when the family fails, someone must step in. If abuse is a certainty at home, then the possibility of abuse elsewhere is a gamble worth taking. The beleaguered state agencies do a yeoman's job most of the time, especially if stable relatives stay involved. You may be less distrustful of them after you have talked with them. Of course, you may be less distrustful of your grandson's father after you have talked with him.

Tags: advice, basic skill, batting averages, dr frank, ejaculations, glaring light, helen singer kaplan, inferiority, insertion, joycelyn elders, masters and johnson, modern sex, orgasms, point man, premature ejaculator, semans, sex experts, sex therapists

Current Issue

Everyday Creativity

How to start living creatively and reap the benefits.

Find a Therapist

Search our customized Directory for a licensed professional near you.