Wounds That Never Heal

The changes in the opioid system might account for what are called the "negative" symptoms of PTSD: emotional numbness, apathy, and lack of zest or interest in life. These negative symptoms often alternate with more flamboyant ones such as nightmares or nervousness, or mix with them in a confusing welter of ups and downs.

In a study by the Harvard Medical School and the VA Medical Center in Manchester, New Hampshire, men with PTSD were shown a harrowing ambush scene from the movie Platoon--twice. The first time, they were given a placebo; the second time, they got naloxone, a drug which acts to block the opioid system.

Find a Therapist

Search for a mental health professional near you.

"We found that veterans with PTSD who watched the movie after having taken the placebo showed a strong drop in their sensitivity to rain while watching," says Roger Pitman, M.D., an associate professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.

Researchers consider such a drop in pain sensitivity to be a direct clue to the workings of the veterans' opioid systems.

Their drop in pain sensitivity, says Dr. Pitman, was blocked by the naloxone. This suggests that the combat stimulus did activate the opioid system to release endorphins, which blunt pain. That may explain the perplexing accounts of mortally wounded soldiers who have continued to fight on, oblivious to the severity of their wounds: Under extreme duress, the body secretes substances that dull the very sensation of pain.

In PTSD, that response seems to continue, sensitizing the nerve pathways regulating endorphins so that they continue to blunt pain--even in reaction to mere images of battle.

This research is all directed toward one ultimate goal: developing new, more effective treatments for PTSD. The preliminary findings have prompted leading pharmaceutical firms to seek medications that will restore a balance to the brain systems that have been altered by trauma. For instance, medication that would block the action of CRF could compensate for that compound's oversecretion. No such drug currently exists.

While there is no medication yet that is specifically effective for all of the brain changes underlying PTSD, some offer partial relief. One is clonidine; another propranolol. Both have been useful for other disorders where there is an excess of adrenaline. But no drugs relieve all of the PTSD symptoms. And no one sees medication as the sole answer.

"Drugs are an adjunct to psychotherapy," says Matthew Friedman, M.D., executive director of the National Center for PTSD and a professor of psychiatry and pharmacology at Dartmouth.

But, he adds, "many PTSD patients are so anxious they can't even participate in therapy. Drugs that tone down their symptoms can make them able. People feel less driven and anxious and can sleep better with fewer nightmares," Dr. Friedman says. "But there are other problems such as alienation, emotional numbness, guilt, and moral pain that only psychotherapy can help solve."

Tags: brain, break wall, dc 10, field of vision, fleeting shadow, fuselage, laguardia airport, mulligan, old advertising, Panic Attack, prostheses, PTSD, robert morris, rural ohio, s sales, sales presentation, television comedy, three pieces, thump, time jerry, trauma, traveling salesman, twigs, usair flight, veteran

Current Issue

Everyday Creativity

How to start living creatively and reap the benefits.